Unfortunately, this is not an unusual scenario. The specific answer will require a review of your contract. If there is no written contract then in general you should give the contractor an opportunity to perform "warranty repairs." But, there are some factual scenarios where a court may agree that you do not owe the bad contractor an opportunity to repair before hiring someone else and charging to the original contractor. I recommend contacting the Robinson and Henry litigation attorneys to review your contract and discuss the facts in a free case assessment prior to making a decision on how to move forward. Just call 303-688-0944 or schedule online at robandhen.wpengine.com/locations