Unfortunately, most issues which involve HOA making demands on Homeowners can only be answered based on a through review of the HOA covenants and by-laws. Generally, I think you are correct WRT the HOAs lack of power to force the Homeowner to make changes to personally owned property. But, it is possible that your HOA does have this authority. The best way to get resolution is to schedule a free case assessment with one of our Homeowner attorneys. You can schedule a free case assessment 24/7 by calling 303-688-0944 or online here. At your appointment, we’ll meet by phone or video (Zoom), we’ll discuss the facts, defenses, concerns, desired results, rights, remedies, the law, the process, timeline, how we can help, costs, etc.