Bases on your facts it seems that the HOA is operating beyond the limits of it's authority. As such you would likely be successful in a lawsuit to stop this action. I recommend that you contact us to schedule a free case assessment with one of our Attorneys (we only represent homeowners against HOAs not HOAs against homeowners. Just call 303-688-0944 (24/7) to schedule or https://calendly.com/case-assessment/case-assessment.